The Reformation’s Legacy
Part 3: The Promise
Last week, we left Martin Luther with an extraordinary discovery.
Christ has done enough.
Jesus has fulfilled the Law. He has borne our sin. He has suffered our punishment. And from the cross, He declared:
Tetelestai.
It is finished.
- Nothing needs to be added to Christ's saving work.
- Not our good works.
- Not our religious accomplishments.
- Not even the strength of our faith.
But that raises another question.
And it's a question that can trouble even the most faithful Christian.
How do I know that Christ did all of this for me?
After all, it's one thing to believe that Jesus died for sinners.
It's another thing entirely to believe that Jesus died for me.
- For my sins.
- For my failures.
- For all those things I have done that I wish I could undo.
- And even those sins I haven't yet recognized.
How can I be certain?
The Problem with Looking Inside
Remember Luther's struggle?
For years, he had searched within himself for assurance that God was gracious toward him.
- Was his repentance sincere enough?
- Was his faith strong enough?
- Had he confessed every sin?
- Was he becoming sufficiently righteous?
But every time Luther looked inward, he found another reason to doubt.
And Christians still do the same thing today.
We know that Jesus died for sinners.
But then we begin examining ourselves.
- Do I really believe?
- Have I truly repented?
- What if my faith isn't genuine?
- What if I've committed the same sin too many times?
- What if God has finally had enough of me?
And before long, we're right back where Luther started.
Looking inside ourselves for evidence that God loves us.
But here's the problem.
Your feelings are not the Gospel!
- Some mornings you wake up feeling close to God.
- Other mornings, you don't.
- Some days your faith seems strong.
- Other days, you wonder whether you have any faith at all.
But God's promises do not become more or less true depending upon how you happen to feel.
Thank God for that!
Because if our salvation depended upon the consistency of our emotions, none of us would have much assurance.
So where does God direct us?
Not deeper into ourselves.
Outside of ourselves.
Remember that little Latin phrase from last week?
Extra nos.
Outside of us.
And here we discover that this principle applies not only to the righteousness by which we are saved, but also to the way God delivers His saving promises to us.
God Doesn't Leave Us Guessing
Think about something for a moment.
If God wanted you to know that your sins were forgiven, how would He tell you?
Would He leave you searching for some special feeling?
Would He expect you to discover forgiveness by measuring the strength of your faith?
Would He require you to look for some extraordinary spiritual experience?
No!
He tells you!
And more than that, He has established particular ways through which He gives you the very forgiveness Christ won upon the cross.
We Lutherans call these the Means of Grace.
Now, that may sound like another complicated theological expression.
But the idea is wonderfully simple.
God doesn't merely accomplish salvation and then leave us wondering whether it belongs to us.
He delivers it.
- Through His Word.
- Through Holy Baptism.
- Through Holy Absolution.
- Through the Lord's Supper.
These aren't religious activities through which we prove our devotion to God.
They are the ways God comes to us with His gifts.
And notice something important.
In each case, God directs our attention away from what we are doing and toward what He is doing for us.
God's Word: The Promise Spoken
St. Paul writes:
“So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ.”
—Romans 10:17
Faith doesn't originate from our ability to manufacture enough religious confidence.
The Holy Spirit creates and sustains faith through the Gospel.
When you hear that Christ died for sinners, that He rose again, and that forgiveness is given freely for His sake, God is not merely sharing interesting religious information.
He is speaking His promise to you.
The Gospel is not simply a report about something that happened two thousand years ago.
It is the living proclamation of what Christ accomplished and what He now gives.
And because the promise comes from God, its truth does not depend upon how convincingly you can reassure yourself.
It depends upon the One who made it.
Holy Baptism: God's Name Upon You
Consider Holy Baptism.
When you were baptized, you weren't simply participating in a ceremony to demonstrate your commitment to Jesus.
God was acting.
Jesus commanded His Church to make disciples by baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit (Matthew 28:19).
And St. Peter proclaimed:
“Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.”
—Acts 2:38
Notice what God attaches to Baptism.
Forgiveness.
The Holy Spirit.
His promise.
Luther understood how precious this was.
In his Small Catechism, Luther explains that Baptism is not simply ordinary water. It is water included in God's command and combined with God's Word.
And what does Baptism give?
Luther answers:
“It works forgiveness of sins, rescues from death and the devil, and gives eternal salvation to all who believe this, as the words and promises of God declare.”
Think about that.
God doesn't simply tell us that He loves us.
In Baptism, He claims us as His own.
He places His name upon us.
He joins us to the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ.
And He gives us the promise of eternal life.
This is why Luther begins his explanation of the Apostles' Creed with those wonderful words:
“I believe that God has made me and all creatures.”
But in Baptism, God does something even more personal.
He makes us His children through faith in Christ.
St. Paul writes:
“For as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ.”
—Galatians 3:27
And again:
“For in Christ Jesus you are all sons of God, through faith.”
—Galatians 3:26
In Baptism, God has made me His own.
- Not because I first made myself worthy of belonging to Him.
- Not because I made some extraordinary commitment.
But because God, in His mercy, has acted.
And that is why Luther could return again and again to the promise of his Baptism.
When doubts and temptations troubled him, he could return to something certain.
I am baptized!
Not because the water possessed some magical power.
But because God's Word and promise were joined to that water.
And here's the beautiful thing.
Your Baptism doesn't change depending upon how you feel about it today.
- You may have a terrible day.
- You may struggle with sin.
- You may feel spiritually weak.
But the promise God made in Baptism remains His promise.
God has placed His name upon you.
He has made you His own.
And when the devil, your conscience, or your fears accuse you, you have something far more certain than your feelings to which you can return.
God's own Word.
Holy Absolution: Christ Speaking to You
And then there is something that many Christians, including some Lutherans, have unfortunately come to overlook.
Holy Absolution.
When the pastor announces the forgiveness of sins, he isn't simply offering encouragement.
He isn't saying, “I think God probably forgives you.”
And he certainly isn't forgiving sins by some personal power or holiness of his own.
Christ Himself entrusted His Church with the authority to forgive sins in His name.
Jesus told His disciples:
“If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you withhold forgiveness from any, it is withheld.”
—John 20:23
And this is where our Lutheran understanding of the pastoral office becomes especially comforting.
When the pastor speaks the words of Absolution, he does so in the stead and by the command of our Lord Jesus Christ.
Those words aren't simply a nice introduction to the forgiveness of sins.
They tell us whose forgiveness is being announced.
Christ's!
The pastor stands before the congregation as Christ's called servant, speaking the forgiveness Christ has commanded His Church to proclaim.
The pastor is not merely describing what Jesus might do.
He is delivering what Jesus has promised.
Christ Himself is speaking through His servant.
This is precisely what Luther teaches in the Small Catechism concerning the Office of the Keys:
“I believe that when the called ministers of Christ deal with us by His divine command, in particular when they exclude openly unrepentant sinners from the Christian congregation and absolve those who repent of their sins and want to do better, this is just as valid and certain, even in heaven, as if Christ our dear Lord dealt with us Himself.”
Read those last words again.
As if Christ our dear Lord dealt with us Himself.
That is extraordinary.
When you hear the pastor pronounce Christ's forgiveness, you are not being asked to place your confidence in the pastor.
You are being directed to the promise and authority of Jesus Christ.
And this comfort is not limited to the pastor's Absolution.
Luther also spoke of the mutual conversation and consolation of the brethren.
Christians are given the privilege of comforting one another with the Gospel.
When a fellow Christian speaks God's forgiveness to a troubled sinner, directs that person to Christ, and reminds them of His promises, Christ's Word is at work there too.
- The authority belongs to Christ.
- The comfort comes from His Gospel.
- The forgiveness is His gift.
The pastor exercises the public Office of the Keys by Christ's call and command. And all Christians may speak the Gospel, forgive one another, and console troubled consciences with the promises of Christ.
Think about that.
You don't have to wonder whether forgiveness is available somewhere out there.
Christ has placed His promise into words that can actually be heard.
Your sins are forgiven!
- Not because your pastor is especially holy.
- Not because you managed to confess with perfect sincerity.
But because Jesus died for sinners and has authorized His Church to announce His forgiveness.
That is why Luther treasured both public and private Absolution.
It takes the Gospel and speaks it directly to the troubled conscience.
For you.
The Lord's Supper: Christ's Body and Blood for You
And perhaps nowhere is this personal assurance more beautifully expressed than in the Lord's Supper.
On the night when He was betrayed, Jesus took bread and wine and gave them to His disciples.
And listen carefully to His words:
“Take, eat; this is my body.”
—Matthew 26:26
And concerning the cup:
“Drink of it, all of you, for this is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins.”
—Matthew 26:27–28
Here is where the Lutheran understanding of the Sacrament becomes so important.
Jesus doesn't merely give us a symbol to help us remember that He loves us.
He gives us His true body and blood, under the bread and wine, for the forgiveness of our sins.
The same body given upon the cross.
The same blood shed for our salvation.
And He gives them with His promise.
Given and shed for you.
Those two little words make all the difference.
Luther's Small Catechism explains:
“These words, ‘Given and shed for you for the forgiveness of sins,’ show us that in the Sacrament forgiveness of sins, life, and salvation are given us through these words.”
Think about the comfort of that.
You may come to the Lord's Table troubled by your sins.
You may come burdened by guilt.
You may come with weak and trembling faith.
But Jesus doesn't tell you to search your heart until you feel sufficiently forgiven.
He says:
Take. Eat.
Take. Drink.
For you.
The certainty isn't found in the strength of the hand receiving the gift.
It's found in the Savior who gives it.
Ad Fontes: Back to the Sources
And now we come to something important about the Reformation itself.
The Lutheran Reformers weren't trying to invent a new Christianity.
They weren't sitting around Wittenberg asking, “How can we come up with something different?”
Quite the opposite.
They wanted to recover what the Church had been given from the beginning.
During the Renaissance and Reformation, scholars frequently used a Latin expression:
Ad fontes.
Back to the sources.
For the Lutheran Reformers, that meant returning above all to Holy Scripture, the inspired Word of God, and examining the Church's teaching and practice in its light.
They also studied the early Church Fathers, not as authorities equal to Scripture, but as witnesses to the faith the Church had confessed throughout the centuries.
The goal wasn't novelty.
It was faithfulness.
And that should sound familiar to anyone who knows the Old Testament.
Remember King Josiah?
In 2 Kings 22–23, we read about a young king who inherited a kingdom that had wandered terribly far from God's Word.
False worship had taken root.
Idolatry had spread.
And the people had neglected the very Word God had given them.
Then, during repairs to the temple, the Book of the Law was discovered.
When Josiah heard God's Word read aloud, he tore his clothes in repentance.
He recognized just how far God's people had wandered.
And what did Josiah do?
He didn't invent a new religion.
He called the people back to the Word of God.
He removed idols, restored the covenant, and celebrated the Passover according to what God had commanded.
It was a reformation
Not by creating something new.
But by returning to what God had already given.
And in many ways, that was the desire of Luther and the Lutheran Reformers.
Ad fontes.
Back to the Scriptures.
Back to Christ.
Back to the Gospel.
Back to the promises God had already made.
And back to the Means of Grace through which Christ delivers those promises to His Church.
The Reformation was not about making Christianity more modern.
It was about being faithful to the Christ who had already accomplished our salvation and had already established how that salvation would be delivered.
Two Little Words That Change Everything
And now we can return to our question.
How do I know Christ's saving work is for me?
Because God doesn't leave you to figure that out by searching your own heart.
- He has spoken His promise.
- He has baptized you into His name.
- He has placed His forgiveness into the words of Absolution.
- He has given His body and blood for you to eat and drink.
All so that you may have something certain.
Something outside yourself.
Something that doesn't rise and fall with your emotions, your spiritual accomplishments, or the strength of your faith.
His Word.
And His Word does what it says.
The Reformation wasn't simply about correcting theological errors or changing church practices.
It was about restoring the comfort of the Gospel to terrified consciences.
The comfort that Christ has accomplished everything necessary for our salvation.
And the comfort that He has not left us guessing whether His gifts are meant for us.
Christ has done enough.
And through His Means of Grace, He delivers what He has accomplished.
For you.
- Not because you have earned it.
- Not because you have finally become good enough.
But because He is gracious.
Because He is faithful.
Because He has promised.
And His promises do not fail.
Next week, we'll bring our series to its conclusion.
If I no longer have to spend my life trying to earn God's favor, what does that mean for the way I live?
If Christ has already done enough, what place do good works have in the Christian life?
And what does Christian freedom actually look like?