The Reformation’s Legacy 

Part 2: The Discovery

Last week, we left Martin Luther with a question:

Have I done enough?

Luther had tried just about everything.

He prayed. He fasted. He confessed. He deprived himself of sleep. He disciplined his body so severely that he later reflected that he had nearly destroyed his health.

If anyone could have beaten the sin out of himself, Luther certainly tried.

And yet, every time Luther looked inside himself for evidence that he was becoming righteous enough for God, he found the same thing:

Sin.

That was the problem.

But it also points us toward the discovery that would change Luther's life—and eventually shake the Western Church.

Luther had been looking in the wrong direction.

The Righteousness of God

One passage of Scripture particularly troubled Luther:

“For in it the righteousness of God is revealed from faith for faith, as it is written, ‘The righteous shall live by faith.’”
—Romans 1:17

Today, we hear “the righteousness of God” and may immediately think of the Gospel.

Luther didn't.

For Luther, God's righteousness was terrifying.

God is righteous.

Luther was not.

If God's righteousness meant that God, as a perfectly righteous judge, gives everyone what he deserves, then a sinner standing before the righteousness of God had a serious problem.

Luther knew what he deserved.

So he hated those words.

He would later write quite candidly that he hated the phrase “the righteousness of God” because he understood it as the righteousness by which the righteous God punishes unrighteous sinners.

But Luther kept wrestling with the text.

And eventually he began to see something he had missed.

Paul wasn't simply telling Luther about the righteousness God demands from him.

Paul was telling him about a righteousness God gives to him.

That changed everything.

Stop Looking Inside

Remember where we ended last week?

Luther had spent years looking inside himself.

  • Was his repentance sincere enough?
  • Was his confession complete enough?
  • Did he love God enough?
  • Had grace transformed him enough?
  • Was his faith strong enough?

And every time Luther went searching inside himself for assurance, he found another reason to doubt.

But the Gospel turned Luther's eyes in an entirely different direction.

Away from Luther.

And toward Christ.

The righteousness by which a sinner stands before God is not finally something God finds within us.

It is Christ's righteousness!

The Reformers sometimes called this an alien righteousness.

That sounds strange to modern ears. “Alien” simply means that this righteousness comes from somewhere outside of me—not little green extraterrestrials! “Alien” simply means not mine.

It belongs to Christ.

  • Jesus has the righteousness I do not have.
  • Jesus has perfectly loved the Father.
  • Jesus has perfectly obeyed the Law.
  • Jesus has perfectly loved His neighbor.
  • Jesus has done what I have not done and could never do.

And then He went to the cross and bore what I deserved!

The astonishing claim of the Gospel is that God takes everything belonging to Christ and gives it to the sinner.

Christ gets my sin.

I get Christ's righteousness.

This is what St. Paul describes:

“For our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.”
—2 Corinthians 5:21

There is the great exchange.

  • My sin for His righteousness.
  • My guilt for His innocence.
  • My death for His life.

And none of it originates in me.

It comes from outside of me.

Extra nos.

Then What About Faith?

This is where we can easily make another mistake.

If we're not careful, we can turn faith into the next thing we have to accomplish.

We stop asking, “Have I done enough good works?”

And start asking:

Have I believed enough?

  • Is my faith strong enough?
  • Is it sincere enough?
  • Do I trust Jesus enough?
  • Do I feel saved enough?

And suddenly we're right back where we started.

Looking inside ourselves.

  • Measuring.
  • Evaluating.
  • Wondering.

Have I done enough?

Only now we've replaced works with faith.

But faith is not another work we perform to convince God to save us.

Faith receives.

Think of an empty hand.

The value isn't in the hand.

The value is in what has been placed into it.

A weak faith does not have a weak Christ.

A trembling faith does not have a trembling Christ.

Our certainty doesn't rest upon how tightly we are able to hold onto Jesus.

It rests upon Jesus.

This is why St. Paul can write:

“For we hold that one is justified by faith apart from works of the law.”
—Romans 3:28

Faith doesn't contribute something missing from Christ's work.

Faith receives Christ.

Christ Has Done Enough

And now we can finally return to the question that tormented Luther.

Have I done enough?

No.

And strangely enough, that is extraordinarily good news.

Because Christianity isn't finally the announcement that God has given you enough assistance to become the person who can answer that question with yes.

The Gospel gives us an entirely different answer.

Christ has done enough.

  • He has obeyed enough.
  • He has loved enough.
  • He has suffered enough.
  • He has paid enough.

In fact, Jesus Himself tells us so.

St. John records Jesus' final moments on the cross:

“When Jesus had received the sour wine, he said, ‘It is finished,’ and he bowed his head and gave up his spirit.”
—John 19:30

“It is finished.”

In Greek, that is just one word:

Tetelestai.

It comes from the Greek word teleō—to complete, accomplish, or bring something to its intended goal.

And here, that one word could almost summarize Jesus' entire saving mission.

Think about it.

Before Jesus was even born, the Holy Spirit had already revealed what He had come to accomplish.

  • The angel told Joseph:

“You shall call his name Jesus, for he will save his people from their sins.”
—Matthew 1:21

Even His name announced His mission.

Jesus—the LORD saves.

From Bethlehem onward, everything moves toward this moment.

  • He came to fulfill the Law we could not fulfill.
  • He came to bear the sin we could not remove.
  • He came to suffer the judgment we deserved.
  • He came to give His life as a ransom for sinners.

And now, hanging upon the cross, Jesus had reached the goal.

  • Nothing remained unfinished.
  • Nothing had been forgotten.
  • Nothing needed to be added.

The mission for which the Son of God had taken on human flesh had been accomplished.

And so, as Jesus prepared to take His final breath, He didn't say:

I have done most of it.

He didn't say:

I have done My part. Now you do yours.

He didn't say:

I have made salvation possible if you can finish the job.

He said:

Tetelestai.

It is finished!

The goal had been reached!

The work had been accomplished.

Christ had done enough!

And that means nothing needs to be added.

  • Not my works.
  • Not my suffering.
  • Not my religious accomplishments.
  • Not the strength of my faith.
  • Not even my improvement as a Christian.

Christ is enough!

And that means the answer Luther spent years desperately searching for could never have been found by looking more deeply into Martin Luther.

It was outside of him all along.

Christ for him.

And the same is true for you.

Your assurance before God is not found by taking your spiritual temperature every morning to determine whether you are sufficiently faithful, sufficiently repentant, sufficiently sanctified, or sufficiently sincere.

Look outside yourself.

Look to Christ.

Because when the question comes again—

Have I done enough?

—the Christian is finally free to answer:

No.

But Christ has.

Tetelestai.

It is finished!

And His righteousness is enough.

Next week, however, another question naturally follows:

That sounds wonderful, Pastor. Christ died for sinners. Christ's righteousness is given as a gift.

But how do I know He means me?

That question will take us to another great legacy of the Reformation:

God doesn't merely tell us that Christ died for the world. He delivers Christ's promise personally to sinners.

Next week:

Part 3 — But How Do I Know It Is for Me?

The Promise