Twelve Weeks of Prayerful Discernment
Listening Together for Where God Is Leading Holy Trinity
Week 10: Testing What We Are Hearing
Scripture Readings
Read:
1 Thessalonians 5:12–24
Acts 15:1–21
Philippians 1:3–11
Reflection
For nine weeks, we have been listening.
- We have listened to God's Word.
- We have prayed.
- We have reflected individually.
- We have talked with one another.
- We have considered our neighbors and their needs.
- We have looked at the gifts God has already placed within Holy Trinity.
And, hopefully, we have begun to notice some recurring themes.
Now comes an important question:
What do we do with what we are hearing?
Paul gives the Thessalonians an important instruction:
“Do not quench the Spirit. Do not despise prophecies, but test everything; hold fast what is good.”
Those words give us a helpful picture of Christian discernment.
Paul does not say:
Accept everything.
Nor does he say:
Reject everything.
He says:
Test everything.
And then:
Hold fast what is good.
That is important for our Season of Discernment.
Over the past several weeks, many thoughts, ideas, concerns, hopes, and possibilities may have emerged.
- Some may be deeply important.
- Some may reflect personal preferences.
- Some may reveal genuine needs.
- Some may simply be interesting ideas.
- Some may confirm things Holy Trinity is already doing well.
- Others may challenge us to reconsider something.
So how do we tell the difference?
We test what we are hearing.
Discernment Begins with God's Word
Our first question cannot simply be:
“Do we like this idea?”
Nor:
“Would this attract more people?”
Nor even:
“Would this work?”
Our first question must be:
“Is this faithful to Christ and His Word?”
God will not lead His Church contrary to what He has already revealed in Scripture.
That gives Christian discernment an anchor.
We are not trying to interpret vague spiritual impressions.
We are listening beneath the authority of God's Word!
Discernment Happens Together
Acts 15 gives us another important picture.
The early Church faced a serious disagreement concerning Gentile believers.
- The apostles and elders gathered.
- They listened.
- They debated.
- They considered what God had been doing.
- They examined the Scriptures.
- And eventually they reached a common judgment.
Notice what they did not do.
One person did not simply announce:
“God told me what we should do.”
The Church discerned together.
That does not mean everyone immediately agreed.
Acts tells us there was “much debate.”
Yet they remained together.
- They listened.
- They searched God's Word.
- They considered God's activity among them.
- And they sought a faithful way forward.
That is an important model for us.
Our conversations with one another are not an optional part of this process.
They are part of the discernment itself.
Look for Recurring Threads
Throughout this series, we have used the image of a tapestry.
One thread by itself may not reveal very much.
But as threads cross one another, a picture begins to emerge.
After nine weeks, perhaps you are beginning to see some of those threads.
- Maybe the same need keeps appearing.
- Maybe several people independently mention the same opportunity.
- Maybe a particular strength of Holy Trinity keeps resurfacing.
- Maybe something we have taken for granted suddenly appears important.
- Maybe a concern continues to emerge in different conversations.
Pay attention to those things.
Not because repetition automatically means God is speaking.
But because recurring themes deserve careful prayer and examination.
And Be Willing to Be Surprised
Paul prays for the Philippians:
“that your love may abound more and more, with knowledge and all discernment, so that you may approve what is excellent.”
Discernment requires humility.
- We may discover that something we assumed was important is not as important as we thought.
- We may discover that something small deserves greater attention.
- We may recognize gifts we overlooked.
- We may hear perspectives very different from our own.
- We may even discover that God has already been answering questions we thought were still unresolved.
That is why we listen.
Not merely to confirm what we already believe.
But because we genuinely want to discern faithfully.
So this week, rather than adding many new ideas, I want us to begin looking backward.
Review your journal.
Remember your conversations.
Look at the previous weeks.
Then ask:
What keeps appearing?
What seems especially consistent with Scripture?
Where do People + Needs + Gifts intersect?
And perhaps most importantly:
What might God be inviting us to pay closer attention to?
Luther's Five Questions
Instruction
- What do these passages teach about discernment?
- Why does Paul tell Christians both to remain open and to “test everything”?
- What can Acts 15 teach us about discerning together as the Church?
- What standards should guide our discernment?
Thanksgiving
- Where have you seen greater clarity emerge during these nine weeks?
- What conversations have helped you see Holy Trinity differently?
- What have you learned about the gifts God has placed within this congregation?
- Where can we thank God for things He is already doing among us?
Confession
- Have I listened primarily for ideas that confirm what I already wanted?
- Have I dismissed another person's perspective too quickly?
- Have personal preferences sometimes become confused with biblical convictions?
- Have fear of change—or desire for change—made it difficult for me to listen carefully?
Petition
- Ask the Holy Spirit for wisdom and discernment.
- Pray that God's Word would remain the standard by which we test everything.
- Ask God to protect us from pride, fear, division, and self-interest.
- Pray for the Planning Committee as it listens to the congregation and begins identifying recurring themes.
Recognition
Look back over the previous nine weeks.
- What themes have appeared repeatedly?
- What needs have several people independently identified?
- What strengths or gifts keep resurfacing?
- What opportunities seem to connect People + Needs + Gifts?
- Is there something you initially overlooked that now seems increasingly important?
Three Layers of Reflection
Personal Reflection
Take out your discernment journal.
Rather than immediately writing something new, read what you have already written.
Then ask:
- What have I written about more than once?
- Has my thinking changed during these nine weeks?
- What surprised me?
- What conviction has grown stronger?
- Is there something I thought was important at the beginning that now seems less important?
- What am I still uncertain about?
Circle or highlight recurring ideas.
Congregational Reflection
Now think about your conversations with other members.
- What have you heard repeatedly?
- Where have people with different perspectives identified the same need or opportunity?
- Where do members seem particularly energized?
- What concerns repeatedly surface?
- Where do you see genuine fruit already occurring?
Try to distinguish between:
“This is something I personally prefer.”
and
“This appears to be something several members are independently recognizing.”
Both can be worth discussing.
But they are not necessarily the same thing.
Discernment Reflection
Return to the framework from Week 9:
People + Needs + Gifts
Ask:
People:
Whom has God placed before us?
Needs:
What needs have we repeatedly recognized?
Gifts:
What has God already entrusted to Holy Trinity?
Then look for intersections.
Where those three repeatedly come together, we may have something worthy of deeper attention.
Write down your three strongest recurring themes from the first nine weeks.
Do not worry about turning them into programs or solutions yet.
Simply name them.
Then share them.
Conversation Challenge
This week's conversation challenge is especially important.
Talk with at least one other member and ask:
“After these first nine weeks, what themes keep coming up for you?”
Then compare notes.
Where do you agree?
Where do you see things differently?
Did the other person notice something you completely missed?
Then ask:
“What do you think the Planning Committee especially needs to hear from us?”
Please share those observations with the Planning Committee.
- Not only polished ideas.
- Not only solutions.
Share questions.
Concerns.
Repeated themes.
Unexpected observations.
And things you are still wrestling with.
The goal is not to produce twelve identical answers.
The goal is to listen faithfully enough that, over time, we begin to recognize the larger picture God may be placing before us.
Our Shared Prayer
Come, Holy Spirit.
Root us in Christ.
Open our hearts to our neighbor.
Send us where You will.
Amen.
We are seeking to faithfully steward what Christ has entrusted to us as we discern where He is leading His Church.