Twelve Weeks of Prayerful Discernment
Listening Together for Where God Is Leading Holy Trinity
Week 11: Seeking Unity in Christ as We Discern Our Direction
Scripture Readings
Read:
Ephesians 4:1–16
Philippians 2:1–11
1 Corinthians 1:10–17
Reflection
For ten weeks, we have been listening.
- Listening to God's Word.
- Listening through prayer.
- Listening to one another.
Looking at the neighbors God has placed before us.
Considering the gifts He has entrusted to Holy Trinity.
And, most recently, testing the themes and observations that have emerged.
Now we arrive at another important question:
How do we move forward together?
That question may sound simple.
But anyone who has spent much time in a congregation knows that Christians do not always see things the same way.
- We have different experiences.
- Different perspectives.
- Different concerns.
- Different hopes.
And sometimes, different ideas about what our congregation should be doing.
That is not necessarily a problem.
After all, as we considered in Week 9, the Church is the Body of Christ, made up of many members with different gifts.
But differences can become a problem when we forget what unites us.
And more importantly, Who unites us.
Unity Is Something Christ Gives
Paul writes in Ephesians:
"Eager to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace."
Notice his language.
He does not tell Christians to create unity.
He tells them to maintain it.
Why?
Because Christian unity is not something we manufacture.
It is something Christ has already given us.
Paul continues:
"There is one body and one Spirit—just as you were called to the one hope that belongs to your call—one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all."
- One Lord.
- One faith.
- One Baptism.
Our unity begins there.
- Not with agreement about programs.
- Not with agreement about budgets.
- Not with agreement about facilities.
- Not even with agreement about what Holy Trinity should look like five or ten years from now.
Our unity begins with Christ.
- He has redeemed us by His blood.
- He has gathered us into His Church.
- He has made us members of His Body through Holy Baptism.
- He continues to nourish and sustain us through His Word and Sacrament.
And because we belong to Him, we also belong to one another.
We are not simply individuals who happen to attend the same congregation. We are brothers and sisters whom Christ has joined together.
That changes how we approach discernment.
Humility Makes Room for Listening
Paul writes to the Philippians:
"Do nothing from selfish ambition or conceit, but in humility count others more significant than yourselves."
Those are challenging words.
Especially when we care deeply about something.
- Perhaps you have a particular ministry that means a great deal to you.
- Perhaps you believe Holy Trinity should pursue a certain opportunity.
- Perhaps you are concerned about a direction others seem excited about.
- Perhaps you have experienced something in the past that makes you cautious about change.
Those perspectives matter.
But Paul reminds us that Christian life is not governed by selfish ambition.
Instead, we are called to have the mind of Christ.
And what does Christ do?
Though He is Lord of all, He humbles Himself.
He takes the form of a servant.
He becomes obedient to death, even death on a cross.
Our Savior does not seek His own advantage.
He gives Himself for us.
And now, as those who belong to Him, we are called to love and serve one another.
That includes listening to one another.
Even when we disagree.
Especially when we disagree.
Unity Does Not Mean Everyone Gets Their Way
There is an important distinction here.
Christian unity does not mean that every opinion is equally faithful to Scripture.
Nor does it mean that we should avoid difficult conversations.
Paul's words in Ephesians call us to speak "the truth in love."
Both matter.
Truth without love can become harsh and divisive.
Love without truth can become empty sentiment.
But truth spoken in love builds up the Body of Christ.
As Confessional Lutherans, we recognize that genuine unity in the Church rests upon agreement in the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments, as our Augsburg Confession teaches in Article VII.
That unity is not established by agreement on every human tradition, preference, or practical arrangement.
This distinction is especially important during our Season of Discernment.
There are matters in which God's Word has already spoken.
On those matters, we are called to faithfulness, not compromise.
But there are also many matters of congregational life in which Christians may faithfully reach different judgments.
- Which opportunities should receive greater attention?
- How should we steward our resources?
- What ministries should we strengthen?
- Where might we need to change our approach?
Those questions require wisdom, patience, prayer, and conversation.
And they require us to remember that getting our preferred outcome is not the same thing as being faithful to Christ.
The Goal Is Faithfulness, Not Winning
Paul addresses divisions in the Corinthian congregation.
Some were saying, "I follow Paul."
Others, "I follow Apollos."
Still others, "I follow Cephas."
Paul responds with a piercing question:
"Is Christ divided?"
It is a question worth remembering.
Our Season of Discernment should never become a contest between competing groups, personalities, or preferences.
We are not trying to determine which group gets its way.
We are seeking to understand how Holy Trinity can most faithfully live as Christ's Church in this place.
And that means we must be willing to listen.
To reconsider.
To acknowledge when someone else has seen something we missed.
To distinguish between what Scripture requires and what we simply prefer.
And sometimes, to set aside a good idea because another opportunity may better serve our neighbors and the congregation's mission.
That is not losing.
That is Christian love.
From Discernment Toward Alignment
Last week, we began looking for recurring themes in our discernment journals and conversations.
- Perhaps certain needs keep appearing.
- Perhaps particular gifts or strengths have become clearer.
- Perhaps several members have independently identified similar opportunities.
Now we begin asking another question:
Where might these observations lead us together?
- Not every idea can become a priority.
- Not every opportunity can be pursued immediately.
- And not every member will necessarily agree about which direction is best.
But we can still move forward together.
Because our unity does not depend upon everyone getting their preferred outcome.
It depends upon Christ, who has already made us His own.
And as we remain rooted in His Word, we can approach the future with humility, charity, courage, and hope.
So this week, I encourage you to consider not only what you believe Holy Trinity should do.
Consider also:
How can we faithfully walk together as Christ's people, even when we see things differently?
That may be one of the most important lessons of this entire journey.
Luther's Five Questions
1. Instruction
What does God's Word teach us?
According to Ephesians 4, what is the foundation of Christian unity?
Why does Paul emphasize humility in Philippians 2?
What dangers does Paul identify in the divisions at Corinth?
What is the difference between unity in Christ and agreement about every practical decision?
How does speaking the truth in love help the Church grow toward maturity in Christ?
2. Thanksgiving
For what can we thank God?
Thank God that He has made us one Body in Christ through Holy Baptism.
Give thanks for the different gifts, experiences, and perspectives represented at Holy Trinity.
Thank Him for members who have faithfully served the congregation, including those whose perspectives differ from your own.
Where have you experienced Christian unity and mutual encouragement within our congregation?
3. Confession
What sins does God's Word reveal?
Have I confused my personal preferences with what God requires?
Have I been too quick to dismiss another member's perspective?
Have I allowed frustration, fear, or pride to shape my conversations?
Have I sometimes been more concerned about getting my way than building up the Body of Christ?
Have I failed to speak the truth in love?
4. Petition
For what should we pray?
Ask the Holy Spirit to preserve Holy Trinity in the unity of the true faith.
Pray for humility, patience, and charity in our conversations.
Ask God to give wisdom to the Planning Committee and congregational leadership.
Pray that our future decisions would be grounded in Scripture and directed toward the faithful proclamation of Christ and service to our neighbors.
Ask the Lord to help us distinguish between biblical convictions, wise judgments, and personal preferences.
5. Recognition
Where might God already be at work among us?
Where have you witnessed members listening respectfully to one another?
What recurring themes appear to unite people who otherwise have different perspectives?
Where do you see a growing shared understanding of Holy Trinity's gifts and opportunities?
What conversations have helped you reconsider or refine your own thinking?
Three Layers of Reflection
Personal Reflection
Take some time to reflect on your own participation in this Season of Discernment.
- Have your thoughts about Holy Trinity's future changed over these eleven weeks?
- Have you discovered something important through listening to another member?
- Is there an idea or preference you have been holding so tightly that you have struggled to consider alternatives?
- How might Christ be calling you to exercise greater humility, patience, or love in this process?
Remember, discernment is not only about what the congregation may do differently.
It is also an opportunity for God's Word to shape us as His people.
Congregational Reflection
Now consider Holy Trinity as a whole.
- What convictions rooted in Scripture should remain central to our identity and mission?
- What recurring themes from our conversations appear to have broad support?
- Where might differences reflect legitimate perspectives rather than disagreements about biblical truth?
- How can we foster conversations in which members feel genuinely heard, even when their suggestions are not ultimately adopted?
- What might help us move forward together with greater clarity and trust?
Discernment Reflection
Return once more to the framework we developed in Week 9:
People + Needs + Gifts
And consider what Week 10 added:
Testing what we are hearing against God's Word.
Now we add another important consideration:
How can we faithfully align our shared efforts around what we are discerning?
Consider these questions:
- Which recurring themes seem most consistent with Holy Trinity's biblical mission and Confessional Lutheran identity?
- Which opportunities seem particularly well matched to the gifts God has entrusted to us?
- Where might concentrating our efforts allow us to serve more faithfully than attempting to do everything?
- What existing ministries should remain central to our congregational life?
- What possibilities deserve further discussion, even if we are not yet ready to act?
- What questions or disagreements still require patient conversation?
As you reflect, try to identify two or three areas where you believe Holy Trinity might faithfully concentrate its attention in the coming years.
These are not votes.
They are not final recommendations.
They are prayerful observations offered for the congregation's continuing discernment.
Please share them with the Planning Committee.
Conversation Challenge
This week, I encourage you to have a conversation with someone whose perspective may be different from your own.
Ask:
"As we look toward Holy Trinity's future, what do you believe we should hold firmly to, and where do you think we may need to be open to change?"
Then listen.
Really listen.
Try to understand not only what the other person believes, but why.
Then ask:
"After these eleven weeks, where do you think we are beginning to find common ground?"
You may discover that beneath different ideas about programs, ministries, or resources, there are shared convictions about the Gospel, our neighbors, and the gifts God has given Holy Trinity.
Record those observations in your discernment journal.
Share them with the Planning Committee.
And remember: